Why Nice Guys Finish Last

We say we want a man to “take charge and lead the relationship.” Yet, we are adamant against relational tyrants. This is all quite understandable. What might add a twist of confusion to the mix is when such a large clump of women end up with tyrants, control freaks, manipulators, and abusers. All the nice guys are left wondering, “What is wrong with me?” Well fellas, here is how this works.

The cocky, take-charge man that we all say we hate has some appeal to his manner of approaching relationships. He knows what he wants and he is confident in his pursuit. That type of guy realizes –at least, some of them do- they may fail. The relationship may go bust. However, that does not stop them or hinder their pursuit. From a girl’s perspective, we can spot insecurity a mile away. After all, many of us are hitched to it like a ball and chain. It is something we hate about ourselves. So, when we see it in a potential mate, we are practically ruthless in shutting that person down. We need someone who will balance us out. Be a rock when we’re a mess, be level-headed when we’re freaking out, and be an open ear when we are rambling a million words per minute.

The female gender is astutely critical. We most often criticize ourselves, but when that cup overflows, we look elsewhere for targets. I am not proud of this, nor do I justify the weakness. But, I do know that it happens. It’s our weakness. It can be an asset when we use the criticism to better ourselves. But when it is exercised to belittle our mate, compare ourselves to other women, or complain about features we cannot change, it isn’t being put to good use.

Here is how nice guys fit into the mix. “She would never go for a guy like me.” “If she really likes me, she’ll talk to me.” The nice guy can be so shy and passive that he doesn’t even ask a girl out. Sometimes, the “nice guy” stereotype comes with something else: insecurity, uncertainty, inability to take charge and lead.

My first love was one of those guys: so very nice… so very insecure. We were snowboarding buddies. I loved how daring he was on the slopes. I wished he would become more daring in our friendship, too. But, he was deathly shy and couldn’t seem to put one relational foot in front of the other. So, I grabbed his hand and lead the way. We liked each other that much I knew. One night, before departing ways he asked me what I was thinking. Being a silly little girl, I told him exactly what was on my mind. “I want to kiss you, but I don’t know how.” Yeah, that was a lie. I knew how. I just wanted him to lead this relationship, not me. Our young love sprouted and we kept seeing each other. But I was the leader. I instigated, I lead, I controlled the relationship, and I hated it. He would look at me, stand near me, tell every other guy not to go for me. But he himself could not make the moves. Miscommunication and lack of leadership on his part lead our relationship on a merry-go-round with no destination. It was a fun ride, but had little purpose. I regret how it all ended, but I wasn’t prepared to get down on one knee and propose to the guy. So I walked away. And like a typical romantic comedy, I wished and prayed he would stop me, come after me. He didn’t.

Sorry guys. This is just how it works. If you are nice, but can’t lead a relationship, things are going to crumble fast. One of two things might happen. Scenario A: it’s a sweet, but boring date and interest chokes with the first bite of food, can’t get resuscitated by dessert, and gets buried when the two say their goodbyes. It’s a hopeless cause. Scenario B: it is an opportunity for the woman to take charge for a bit. She’ll lead the relationship awhile until she grows bored or meets a confident leader who can make decisions and hold a conversation. They say nice guys finish last. Sometimes they do. And this is why. Women crave men with leadership abilities and confidence. Women will go for a confident man over a “nice guy” 99% of the time. The key is to become both.

Nice Guy, put yourself out there more. Take chances. You may fail thirty-seven times, but when it does work, it is worth it. Be confident in this: you are exactly who you are supposed to be. God created you a specific way. There is a type of girl who is madly wild about your character. So be confident, be bold. Don’t put a lot of pressure on yourself to say all the right things and ask all the right questions. We’re learning together. Just roll with it. If you make a mistake, shrug it off. Life is fun and relationships are incredible gifts from God. Treat every woman like you’d want your sister or future wife to be treated and you will leave every girl better off than before she knew you.

I respect a man who will put himself out there. I’m not talking about the creepy guy that accosts me in Wal-Mart ranting about my outer beauty. I’m talking about the budding friendship that clicks well. Most of the time, I’ll say yes to a date, especially if a friendly platform has been established first. There, that should be the hardest step covered. The actual date is the fun part. A plan is good. Questions are great. But stress is unnecessary. It seems like a lot of pressure, but there is only one thing you need to do on this date: be confident in yourself. Now, if the date doesn’t go well, so be it. Not every girl is the right fit. The confidence part is what you can control. If you are confident you will shine and exude a certain authenticity that is attractive. That is how you will have a good date, regardless of the outcome.


About Mackenzie

Traveling is ingrained in my DNA. I was born in Texas. Raised all over the U.S. I love mission work, the medical field, ingesting copious amounts of knowledge, and honorable relationships. I'm quite passionate about health, purity, sports, and the Bible. So, there's that! View all posts by Mackenzie

4 responses to “Why Nice Guys Finish Last

  • a.w. marks

    Mackenzie, good to see you posting again!

    I started a relationship with an amazing woman named Andrea three months ago — it’s amazing how much I can testify to the merits of leading confidently. As one often deemed the “nice guy,” I can attest to how easy it is to stand back and hope nothing is required for God to drop a woman into my life. And that’s exactly it: the waiting is easy. It’s also fruitless. I think men in the church have been a bit brainwashed into thinking that a God-honoring relationship means waiting for every wonderful thing to happen, because we’re somehow being inconsiderate or disobedient if we state our true intentions with a woman.

    If I can give one piece of advice to the nice guys out there, it is this: if your intentions to date are noble and pure, there’s no reason not to state them confidently. Yes, there’s the possibility that she won’t be interested, but I’d much rather be rejected for the exact thing I have in mind than to dance around the potential and have her reject something short of my intent.

    Every worthwhile woman requires a risk; when we’re unwilling to accept that we’re worthy of taking that risk, we communicate the same to the woman. How can we blame her for drawing that conclusion?

    It had been ten years since my last relationship, aside from single dates here and there. While on a date in which I wanted to kiss Andrea more than anything, I reasoned that she had more business being with a God-fearing man than some jerk out there, and I had no reason not to take confidence in that. She knew my history — by kissing her I demonstrated that I wasn’t waiting for some mythical sign to tell me it was okay to pursue her further, or that I thought myself less than a worthy man of God. Ever the considerate type, she responded (after kissing back) by saying, “You didn’t have to do that.” I confidently replied, “Yes I did.” 🙂

    Is leading hard? Yes, it can be as terrifying as any act of faith. But that’s the work to be done between man and God — He is the one that strengthens us and gives us hope. We men can do our ladies of interest the favor of not dropping the burden of doubt on them.

    • Mackenzie

      Aww, thank you so much! It means a heap to read confirmation from a GUY’S perspective. I should have responded sooner. I really appreciated your comment, but fell off the face of the Earth again and never got back on here. So much for becoming an avid blogger. 😉

      Also, I’m so happy for you! Thank you for sharing your story. And good job! It really sounds like a blessed relationship. I pray you continue to grow closer to Christ and your beautiful girl through this experience. Blessing to you, bro!!

      Thanks so much for all your support. You’ve been a wise counselor and welcomed reader on my blog. Always great to hear from you! Sincerely! 🙂

  • Josiah Rosie

    Legit Kenzie!! 😀 Good, and Challenging!!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: